28
Feb

Atap Rumah Sakit Roboh!!

Written by Gouw Tjie Liong, Ir., M.Eng, ChFC, PhD. Posted in Geotechnic, News and Opinion

Baru saja terima berita ada bangunan rumah sakit yang roboh atapnya! Tidak etis menyebut namanya. Cuma ini benar benar konyol!!

Bangunan rumah sakit, klinik, markas damkar, markas polisi, gudang sembako termasuk bangunan penting. Yang harus bertahan segala cuaca dan bahkan tahan gempa serta tak mudah terbakar. Coba bayangkan bila ada bencana gempa misalnya rumah sakit rumah sakit, klinik klinik, markas damkar, kantor polisi, gudang sembako pada roboh duluan dan terbakar (biasanya gempa sering diikuti kebakaran karena korsleting listrik , kompor yg sedang menyala saat gempa, dan pipa gas yang bocor) .

Adalah bodoh dan konyol sekali bila tidak pakai konsultan handal untuk merencanakan struktur bangunan bangunan penting tersebut!!

Pernah saya diminta pendapat oleh seorang junior enjinir yang baru lulus 2-3 tahun. Katanya dia dapat order desain rumah sakit 3 lantai. Saya anjurkan agar ikut yg senior dulu biar ada pengalaman sebab walau cuma dua-tiga lantai bangunan itu harus handal dan kokoh berdiri dalam segala cuaca dan gempa. Ini berarti desain pondasi, struktur gedung, fasilitas mechanical dan electrical, serta fasilitas pemipaan oxygen dan lain lain terkait peralatan dan perlengkapan rumah sakit harus di desain dengan koordinasi yang baik. Yang mana enjinir muda sering kurang pengalaman. Bukan mengecilkan pengalaman enjinir muda, tetapi sebaiknya bila belum pernah mendesain bangunan vital sebaiknya minta advis senior berpengalaman.

GTL, 201030

12
Apr

How Do Problems Arises in Geotechnical Works?

Written by Gouw Tjie Liong, Ir., M.Eng, ChFC, PhD. Posted in Geotechnic, News and Opinion

The problems faced by engineers in dealing with soils lie not only on the fact soils are particulate material which have much more complex behavior compared to concrete and steel, but it is also lie to the attitude of those engineers who have no enough “respect” toward the soils they faced.

Soils need to be understood and to be well treated, just like we try hard to understand and to treat a lady. There are four aspects of geotechnic that we need to learn and to understand, those are:

– The soil profiles (type and distribution)

– The ground water table, i.e. , its position, indication of ground water flow, existence of perched water table and artesian water pressure.

– Characteristics and behavior of the existing subsoils

– The right soil model to be taken for designing the planned geotechnical structure.

For all the above, time and money need to be invested. Ask the rich and successful peoples, whether they “invested” time and money to chase for the ladies that eventually became their wives?
Like those ladies, in order to understand the soil behavior, time and money also need to be given (invested) to the soils,

If the engineers understand the above four aspects well, then “comfort” will be belong to the engineers, and ultimately will also belong to the owner and the end users of the said structures / buildings.

On the other hand, if we treat the soils badly, and only give the soils unreasonable amount of time and money, just like cruel parents treat their step children badly. Then: “just wait for the retaliation” of the step children.

You don’t believe me? Look back to the failure of Sano Tower at Pluit area, North Jakarta, in 1991; or to the current “failure” of “S tower” near Cawang, South Jakarta; or to the badly settled “GB tower” at Pluit, North Jakarta. Look back to the Nicoll highway deep excavation (for MRT station) failure in Singapore in 2004; and many other geotechnical failures.

One of the causes of the those failures is the attitude of IGNORANCE or DO NOT CARE or “ASSUMED” TO KNOW BETTER than any other engineers. The over insistence of saving money, all the owner know is only SAVE, SAVE and SAVE. They do not want to spend time and money for soil investigation, and the engineers involved failed to convince the owner to spend the money!! The owner even want to save more, by using bidding process, to suppress the consultant!!! They forgot the words: “You buy peanuts, you get monkeys!”. They feel they are so clever and so able to get cheap price!!! They only want to higher engineers with low fees!!! They forgot CHEAP is not the same as ECONOMICAL. Indirectly, they treat the soils, where their structures shall be built, as step children!!

Then, one day, the step children will retaliate, and when they do so, the retaliation can be so destructive and fatal!!

So, go and tell the owner of the money: 
TREAT THE SOIL AS A LADY, THEN THE COMFORT IS YOURS.
TREAT THE SOIL AS A STEPCHILDREN, THE REVENGE IS WAITING FOR YOU!!

Written by Gouw Tjie Liong(English version: April 12, 2015)

 

Geotechnical Course

  • Soil Mechanis
  • Soil Investigation
  • Foundation Engineering
  • PIT, PDA, Sonic Logging
  • Slope Stabilization
  • Geotechnical Instrumentation
  • Deep Excavation
  • Ground Improvement
  • Geotechnical Instrumentation
  • Earthquake
  • Liquefaction Analysis
  • Application of Geotechnical Software
  • Other Geotechnical Course

Learn more

Motivational Course

  • Cultivating Engineering Judgment
  • The Problem of Engineer
  • How I Present Myself
  • Light Up
  • Toward Successful Engineering Career
  • Pressure lead to Success
  • The Up and Down of My Life
  • Theory of Emptiness
  • Turning Thought into Reality
  • Young Engineer